The Best Ice Cream in Pigeon Forge: Top 5 Creameries and Shops

When the weather gets warm in Pigeon Forge, TN, nothing hits the spot like some ice cream! Our Smoky Mountain city is filled with a number of superb creameries and shops where you can enjoy everyone’s favorite vacation treat. To help you make the most of your next getaway, we have put together a guide to finding the best ice cream in Pigeon Forge.

1. The Old Mill Creamery

The Old Mill Creamery is a classic after-dinner destination in Pigeon Forge! Located in The Old Mill Square, this popular ice cream parlor is the perfect place to get a cone, shake, sundae, float, or malt. Many of the Creamery’s signature ice cream flavors use ingredients from neighboring shops in the square, such as Salted Caramel (made with caramel from The Old Mill Candy Kitchen), Whiskey Ribbon (made with moonshine from The Old Forge Distillery), and Oat Mill Cream Pie (made with rolled oats from The Old Mill).

2. Curl de la Creme

Curl de la Creme is Pigeon Forge’s newest and most unique ice cream shop. This one-of-a-kind store serves “curled ice cream”, a special dessert that is made by pouring cream onto a below freezing stainless steel plate, spreading it into a thin sheet, and rolling it up. Curl de la Creme currently offers two base flavors (vanilla or chocolate), 13 mix-ins, and around 20 different toppings. Half the fun of visiting Curl de la Creme is seeing the liquid cream turn into ice cream right before your eyes! Check out the video below to get a sneak peek of the process:

3. Mad Dog’s Creamery & Donuts

Mad Dog’s Creamery & Donuts makes some of the very best ice cream in Pigeon Forge. Guests can choose from 24 spectacular flavors of ice cream, including classic varieties like Mint Chocolate Chip and Moose Tracks, and more adventurous creations, such as Blueberry Pie and Strawberry Cheesecake. Whether you enjoy your ice cream as a cone, sundae, or shake, you can’t go wrong at Mad Dog’s. As you may have guessed by their name, this shop also offers delicious donuts!

4. The Island Creamery

Conveniently located at The Island in Pigeon Forge, The Island Creamery is a wonderful place to grab a snack during a shopping trip. All of the ice cream at this parlor is freshly made in-house. Popular flavors at The Island Creamery include Banana Pudding, Fruity Pebbles, Butterscotch Brownie, and Rocky Road. The portions are very generous at The Island Creamery, so a single scoop in a waffle cone usually does the trick for most adults.

5. Mel’s Classic Diner

Mel’s Classic Diner is a blast from the past! This ‘50s-style restaurant has classic American food and fantastic ice cream. With sundaes, milkshakes, malts, and floats, you’re sure to find a dessert you love. Our personal favorite is Mel’s Ultimate Banana Split, which you can order with three scoops or six scoops of ice cream. Watch the video below to take a look inside the diner:

Final Thoughts

Who do you think has the best ice cream in Pigeon Forge? Let us know in the comments below!